Voters in the Netherlands are preparing to potentially replace the most conservative government in modern history with a more centrist and pragmatic coalition during snap parliamentary elections scheduled for October 29.
The Situation and Why It Matters
Early legislative elections were triggered after the collapse of the outgoing administration in June, when rightwing politician Geert Wilders pulled his PVV from an increasingly fractious and largely ineffective governing alliance.
The PVV had achieved a surprising first place in the previous general election, and after extended negotiations established a fragile four-party conservative alliance with the BBB party, NSC party and liberal-conservative VVD.
Nevertheless, Wilders' coalition partners considered him too toxic for the prime minister position, which ultimately went to a former intelligence chief. Wilders, an immigration-skeptic commentator who has required security detail for two decades, began criticizing from the sidelines.
He ultimately triggered the coalition breakup on 3 June after his partners refused to adopt a far-reaching comprehensive anti-immigration plan that included deploying the army to guard frontiers, rejecting all refugee applicants, shutting down refugee hostels and repatriating all Syrian refugees.
While backing of the PVV has decreased, polls indicate the rightwing, anti-Islam party is again likely to secure the largest representation in parliament. However, main Dutch political parties have collectively rejected forming a government with Wilders.
No fewer than 16 parties are predicted to gain representation, but no single party is projected to win more than approximately 20% of the vote. As usual, the future Netherlands administration, generally an significant force on the EU and world stage, will be formed following coalition negotiations that could take several months.
How the System Works and Party Environment
The parliament contains 150 MPs in the Dutch parliament, meaning a government needs 76 mandates to achieve majority status. No individual group typically achieves this, and the Holland has been ruled by coalitions for more than a century.
Representatives are chosen every four years – earlier if administrations fail – through proportional representation, based on an certified roster of contenders in a single, nationwide constituency: any political group that secures 0.67% of the vote is guaranteed a seat.
As in much of Europe, Dutch politics have been marked in modern times by a significant drop in support for the historical ruling parties from the centre-right and left, whose electoral support has decreased from over four-fifths in the 1980s to just over 40% now.
In the Netherlands, this process has been accompanied by a spectacular proliferation of minor political groups: twenty-seven are competing this time, including a senior citizens' party, a young people's party, a animal rights party, a party for universal basic income, and a sports-focused party.
Key Players and Main Issues
In the lead is Wilders' PVV, forecast to drop as many as eight of the 37 seats it won in 2023. It advocates, among other measures, a total moratorium on asylum, male Ukrainian refugees to be returned, the military to fight "urban violence", and an end to "progressive education" in schools.
Two parties, of the moderate right and left, are neck-and-neck behind the PVV. The Christian Democrats (CDA) dominated Netherlands government from the end of the seventies to the beginning of the nineties, and once more in the early 2000s, but dropped to only five mandates in the last election.
Nevertheless, under Henri Bontenbal, its promising new figure, who entered politics only four years ago, the party has recovered strongly with a electoral platform highlighting the dire Dutch housing crisis and a promise of "normal, civilised politics". It is projected for up to twenty-six mandates.
GreenLeft/Labour (GL/PvdA), an electoral alliance between the green party and the 80-year-old Dutch Labour party that is expected to become a complete unification, is on track to win a similar number, according to polling averages.
Led by the experienced former European commissioner Frans Timmermans, it has made building more new homes its biggest priority, and has controversially included a immigration limit of between 40,000 and 60,000 people a year in its manifesto.
Three additional groups look likely to be significant forces in the next legislature.
The liberal-progressive D66 is on course to increase representation – securing as many as seventeen, from its present nine – under its direct-speaking young leader, with a platform focused on residential construction (it plans to build 10 new cities) and an "personal minimum income" for recipients.
The center-right VVD, the party of the ex-premier (now Nato chief), is forecast to decline to no more than sixteen mandates from its present twenty-four, with its head, criticized of moving the group excessively rightward, blamed for its decrease. It is promising business tax cuts and less welfare.
The populist, strictly rightwing JA21 is a breakaway group from another far-right party – the previously successful, now scandal-hit FvD – and seems to be benefiting from an exodus of voters from the three major rightwing parties. It could win up to 14 seats.
In addition to the two main rightwing parties, both remaining members in the unsuccessful previous government, the BBB and NSC, are expected to lose out, with the NSC not even sure of legislative seats.
The primary concerns so far have been immigration, with multiple – sometimes violent – demonstrations against planned emergency reception centres for refugee applicants, the cost of living, and the perennial Dutch problem of accommodation (the country is lacking four hundred thousand residences).
Potential New Government
Given the highly fragmented state of Dutch politics, what alliances are actually possible is just as important as who wins the election (or in this case, probably runner-up, since no major party will partner with Wilders, who maintains he intends to lead a minority government).
After the election, MPs first designate an informateur, who seeks out possible alliances. Once a viable coalition has been identified, a formateur, typically the head of the largest potential partner, begins discussing the formal coalition agreement. This can take months.
Multiple options look plausible, most involving a combination of parties from moderate left and center right. The most probable, according to coalition experts, include Christian Democrats and GreenLeft/Labour, plus Democrats 66 and several smaller parties potentially including JA21.